• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Family Focus Blog Header

Family Focus Blog

A top mom blogger shares everything from parenting tips to family travel advice.

  • Activities & Crafts
  • Home Decor
  • Green Living
  • Family Food
  • Family Travel
  • Lifestyle
  • Parenting
You are here: Home / Activities & Crafts / DIY Easter Basket Stuffers: Handmade Gifts for a Personal Touch

DIY Easter Basket Stuffers: Handmade Gifts for a Personal Touch

April 2, 2025 by Scarlet

89 shares
  • Share43
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • Threads

Easter season is fast approaching. Easter often coincides with the arrival of spring in many parts of the world. Giving gifts can be a way to celebrate the new season and the renewal of life. For Christians, Easter is a significant religious holiday that commemorates the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Gift-giving may symbolize the joy and generosity associated with this event. So I am excited to share some DIY Easter basket stuffers for toddlers with you. I think you will enjoy these ideas for DIY Easter basket stuffers and find them fun, frugal, and a lot healthier than a bunch of candy! These Easter basket fillers are good for younger kids and older kids alike.

Kids Will Love These Fun Easter Baskets Stuffers

DIY non-candy Easter basket stuffers

Like other holidays, Easter is a time of joy and festivity. Giving and receiving gifts can add to the sense of celebration and happiness. Easter is hopping our way soon, and although Easter baskets are a fun holiday tradition, the Easter bunny may feel the need to lay a golden egg to pay for it all. Special occasions all too often become the catalyst for an out-of-balance budget. However, with a little bit of time and effort, it is possible to create a bountiful bargain Easter basket with the following inexpensive do-it-yourself ideas that don’t require innate craftiness to accomplish.

With Easter just around the corner, it’s time to add a personal touch to your celebrations. This year, why not ditch the store-bought gifts and opt for handmade Easter basket stuffers that will truly show your loved ones how much you care? From personalized keepsakes to delicious treats, get ready to craft your way to a memorable holiday season. Join us as we explore DIY stuffer ideas that will make this Easter one to remember!

1. DIY Finger Paints

Invite some creative fun into your life and make finger paint. Simply combine three tablespoons of sugar, ½ teaspoon of salt, ½ cup of corn starch and two cups of water in a small saucepan and warm until thickened. Cool and pour into glass baby food jars and then add in enough drops of food coloring to create the desired hue. Nestle the colors together inside of your container for a rainbow of artistic possibility at very little cost.

diy crayons in easter bunny shapes

2. DIY Crayons

A second idea for Easter basket stuffers is DIY crayons. If finger painting is more of a potential for mess than you are willing to take on, consider giving old crayons new life by searching for all of the broken crayon pieces in the art supply box, removing their wrappers and chopping them up into pea-sized pieces. Place the colorful crayon bits in a pre-greased muffin tin and bake. Once they cool, pop them from the makeshift mold and package together with cellophane and ribbon for a cute gift (that has the added benefit of being the perfect size for chubby little hands). Your kids will love the full tutorial for learning to make crayons. Crayons, markers, coloring books, or other art supplies can provide hours of creative fun.

3. Personalized Keepsakes

Still want more Easter basket filler ideas? Kids will enjoy personalized keepsakes that will make this Easter one to remember. From customized keychains to monogrammed jewelry, these thoughtful gifts add an extra layer of sentiment to your DIY Easter baskets.

play dough recipe for kids

4. DIY Play Dough

All natural DIY play dough is always a hit. Encourage mini-sculptors to use their imagination with this safe-to-ingest clay that’s so cheap and easy to create that you won’t even cringe when the colors get mixed together into one giant clump.

Here’s the recipe: Stir ½ cup of salt, ½ cup of water and 1 cup of flour together in a medium-sized bowl until well mixed. Add drops of food coloring and knead the dough on a surface covered with newspaper until the color becomes vibrant. Store the dough in small plastic food storage containers with decorative labels attached. Small toys like play dough, toy cars, bouncy balls, bubbles, or figurines are great for filling Easter baskets.

5. DIY Sidewalk Chalk

The arrival of spring means more sunny days, so get ready for some outdoor fun and to make the world (specifically the sidewalk) a more colorful place with this easy recipe. Just mix one cup of Plaster of Paris, ¾ cup of water, and Tempera paint for color in a large bowl. Coat the inside of plastic Easter egg halves with petroleum jelly and pour the mixture inside. Once the chalk seems like it is beginning to dry, attach the two egg halves and allow to fully dry. Once finished, remove your chalk eggs from the plastic forms and set them aside to harden for an additional 24 hours before use. Present them prettily by lining the eggs up in a small egg carton and including it in the basket. Sidewalk chalk, jump ropes, or small sports equipment can encourage outdoor play.

making finger puppets

6. DIY Finger Puppets

Encourage the right kind of drama with a toy made with love that also promotes pretend play. Cut the fingers off of gloves and glue on googley eyes, pom-poms, felt pieces and bits of pipe cleaner to create characters, monsters or animal puppet performers. Remember that they don’t have to be perfect to be fun–kids don’t know that craft mavens like Martha Stewart exist, and since the Easter bunny doesn’t have elves like Santa, his work may not live up to the same professional standards. Make the imperfection part of the process and don’t let it stop you from attempting slightly more intimidating crafts. You can also try these easy bunny finger puppets. Alternatively, a cute plush bunny or chick can be a cuddly addition to the basket. These are the perfect easter basket stuffer for little kids over 3 years of age that have stopped introducing everything to their mouths! (They could be a choking hazard for babies!)

7. Lip Balm

For a delightful addition to your Easter baskets, consider making your own lip balm. Homemade lip balm is a simple yet luxurious gift that is sure to be appreciated by anyone who receives it. With just a few natural ingredients and a little bit of creativity, you can create a personalized lip balm that will keep lips soft and moisturized all year round.

bath bombs silicone mold

8. Bath Bombs

For a spa-like experience at home, try making your own bath bombs to add to your Easter baskets. Bath bombs are a fun and fizzy way to enhance bath time, leaving skin feeling soft and rejuvenated. By crafting your own bath bombs, you can customize them with your favorite scents, colors, and even hidden surprises inside. These DIY bath bombs are a perfect addition to your handmade gifts, adding a touch of relaxation and luxury to your Easter celebration. Soak in the joy of giving with these delightful treats that will make anyone’s Easter a little more special.

9. Handmade Easter Treats

One way to add a delicious touch to your DIY Easter baskets is by including handmade treats. Whether it’s a batch of homemade cookies, specially crafted chocolate eggs (filled with jelly beans), or adorable chocolate bunnies, these treats are sure to delight your loved ones. Handmade treats not only show effort and thoughtfulness, but they also add a personal element to your Easter basket gifts.

Easter basket stuffers

Conclusion

I hope you enjoy these ideas for the best Easter basket stuffers. If you’re going to make your own Easter goodies from scratch, you will need to hop to it as the holiday is quickly approaching. Although the original intention in going the do-it-yourself route may have been to cut costs, you might also find that keeping it simple and from the heart will bring a sense of wonder and whimsy to your baskets that will help make them truly memorable. Do you have any special Easter Egg Hunt traditions?

These are just a few ideas to get you started. Tailor the basket stuffers to the child’s interests and age for a personalized and enjoyable Easter basket. Easter-themed books or any book that matches the child’s interests can be a thoughtful gift. Who knew the Easter bunny was so egg-cellent at creative, cost-cutting DIY crafts?  Which are your favorite DIY non-candy Easter Basket stuffers for kids of all ages?  If you have more ideas for DIY Easter basket stuffers, feel free to share them in the comments.  We’d love to hear your DIY Easter basket ideas!

Related Posts:

Easter Basket Ideas for Babies

Make Transfer Paper T Shirts With These Free Printable Easter Images

DIY Easter Decorations To Bring Cheer To Your Home

89 shares
  • Share43
  • Tweet
  • Flipboard
  • Threads

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Parenting Tips at Uplifting Families says

    April 1, 2014 at 8:19 pm

    These easter basket gifts are great. My kids love sidewalk chalk. Don’t forget to check dollar tree for the best deals on some of these great Easter gifts.

  2. Kristin Llamas says

    April 4, 2014 at 1:51 pm

    So many fun Easter basket filler ideas! With 3 girls under 6yrs, we love “non-candy” items for Easter baskets but hate cluttering toy boxes with little junk so we always gear toward crafts and books! Mini puzzles, a coloring book, card games, or travel-sized board games are fun and portable too! Any one of those make the perfect Easter basket gift.

  3. Jane says

    April 3, 2025 at 12:41 am

    Love these Easter basket stuffer ideas! Sensory play items are such a fun way to engage little ones while also helping with fine motor skills. These fun items make kids’ Easter baskets extra special, and it’s great to see options that go beyond just candy. Perfect baskets for a memorable holiday!

  4. Demi says

    April 3, 2025 at 6:50 am

    I love how these ideas make kids’ Easter baskets both exciting and meaningful! It’s a fun way to include items that spark creativity and hands-on learning. Perfect baskets should have a mix of fun items and activities, and sensory play additions make the experience even better!

  5. furrmate says

    April 4, 2025 at 7:38 am

    I adore how these ideas make children’s Easter baskets fun and meaningful! It’s a wonderful approach to incorporate materials that promote creativity and hands-on learning. Perfect baskets should include a variety of enjoyable things and activities, and sensory play enhances the experience even more!

  6. Kidzonia says

    April 5, 2025 at 3:16 am

    These Easter basket stuffer ideas are absolutely adorable! I especially love the personalized painted rocks. What a creative way to add a special touch. Thank you for the inspiration!

  7. Claudia Klein says

    April 6, 2025 at 12:01 am

    Great suggestions on making Easter baskets more personal! I love how practical and eco-friendly your ideas are. Thanks for the helpful tips, and happy crafting!

Primary Sidebar

Let's Be Friends!

Welcome To Family Focus Blog

Family Blogger
Thanks for reading Family Focus Blog, a parenting and lifestyle blog that provides tips, advice, and inspiration for families. It covers a wide range of topics, including parenting tips, family-friendly recipes, eco-friendly living, family travel, home decor, and family activities. The blog was created in 2010 by Nashville mom blogger, Scarlet Paolicchi. She shares her personal experiences and practical advice for raising children and maintaining a balanced family life. Scarlet Paolicchi is the author of four books, available through her affiliate link on Amazon.

Footer

Popular Posts

Chocolate Pudding Pie Recipe
Lord of The Rings Recipes
Why Is Family Important?
Bible Verses About Parenting Responsibilities
Zucchini Pie Recipe
Family Oriented Meaning

Disclosure

Family Focus Blog is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program. We also accept forms of cash advertising and sponsorship. We disclose material relationships and share honest opinions.
Privacy Policy

Copyright

© Scarlet Paolicchi and Family Focus Blog, 2010-2024. Short excerpts of this family blog may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Family Focus Blog with link back to the original content. Duplicating a whole post is strictly prohibited.

Copyright © 2025